.png){kind=small}
Substack vs Medium vs Beehiiv 2026: Which Pays More for Writers?
- BizToolKit
- 1 day ago
- 6 min read
Writers building an online audience in 2026 face a genuinely important platform decision: Substack, Medium, and Beehiiv each represent a different philosophy about how writing should be distributed, monetized, and owned. Substack is the subscription-first platform that made newsletter monetization mainstream. Medium is the reader-supported platform that pays writers based on engagement rather than subscriptions. Beehiiv is the growth-focused platform built for serious newsletter operators. This guide compares all three across monetization, growth tools, ownership, and economics.
Platform Overview
Substack launched in 2017 and pioneered the paid newsletter model for independent writers. Its core premise: writers should be able to charge readers directly for their content, without advertisers or algorithms determining what gets distributed. Substack provides a clean publishing interface, built-in payment processing (through Stripe), and a basic recommendation algorithm that suggests relevant newsletters to readers. Substack takes 10% of all paid subscription revenue.
Medium has been publishing since 2012 and operates on a fundamentally different model: a single subscription ($5/month) where readers access all Medium content, and writers earn based on how much time paying subscribers spend reading their stories. Medium's Partner Program pays writers from a shared revenue pool based on read time — not per subscriber or per article sold. There are no direct reader-to-writer subscriptions on Medium.
Beehiiv launched in 2021, founded by former Morning Brew team members who built large newsletters before starting Beehiiv. It was purpose-built for newsletter operators who want advanced growth tools, sophisticated analytics, and the ability to monetize through multiple channels (subscriptions, ads, and paid recommendations) simultaneously. Beehiiv takes 0% of subscription revenue on paid plans ($39/month and up).
Monetization Comparison
Substack monetization: Reader subscriptions are the primary revenue model. Writers set their own subscription price (most commonly $5-$10/month or $50-$100/year) and Substack takes 10% of all revenue. A newsletter with 1,000 paid subscribers at $8/month earns approximately $7,200/month net after Substack's cut and Stripe processing fees. Writers with 100+ paid subscribers can apply for Substack's Recommendations program, which boosts their newsletter in Substack's discovery algorithm.
Medium monetization: Writers earn from Medium's Partner Program based on member reading time. Monthly earnings vary enormously — a viral story can earn $1,000-$5,000 in a single month; a typical story earns $0.50-$50. Most writers earn $100-$500/month total from Medium, with top writers earning $1,000-$5,000/month. The model rewards consistent publishing across many stories rather than a single blockbuster newsletter — it's better suited to writers who prefer ad-supported breadth over subscription depth.
Beehiiv monetization in 2026: Three simultaneous revenue streams. (1) Paid subscriptions: 0% platform fee on Scale plan and above, so writers keep approximately 97% after Stripe fees. (2) Beehiiv Ad Network: Brands pay to place ads in newsletters across the Beehiiv network — writers with 1,000+ subscribers can opt in and earn $1-5 per 1,000 subscribers per send depending on niche. (3) Boosts (paid recommendations): Other newsletters pay to be recommended in your post-subscription sequence — writers earn $1-3 per new subscriber they drive to other newsletters.
For a detailed breakdown of what newsletter writers actually earn at different subscriber levels, read our guide on How Much Do Substack Writers Make in 2026 — which covers paid conversion rates, subscription pricing strategies, and real income reports from established writers.
Growth and Discovery Tools
Substack's growth tools in 2026: Substack's Recommendations feature (where writers recommend each other's newsletters, surfaced to subscribers) is the platform's most powerful organic growth tool. Substack Notes (a Twitter/X-like short-form feed within Substack) has added a new discovery surface in 2026. The Substack app has become an increasingly meaningful traffic source as mobile newsletter consumption grows. However, Substack's search and discovery is still limited compared to established content platforms.
Medium's growth tools: Medium's algorithm distributes stories to readers based on topic tags and reading history — a well-tagged story in a popular topic can reach tens of thousands of readers organically, regardless of the writer's follower count. This makes Medium the best platform for cold organic reach — a new writer can get 10,000 reads on their first story if it's well-written and well-tagged, which is impossible on Substack without an existing audience. Medium also distributes to partner publications (Towards Data Science, The Startup, Better Programming) with their own large readerships.
Beehiiv's growth tools: Beehiiv's Boosts network (where you pay other newsletters to recommend your newsletter to their subscribers) and referral program (where subscribers earn rewards for referring friends) are its defining growth mechanisms. Beehiiv's analytics are the most sophisticated of the three platforms — open rates, click rates, subscriber growth curves, and cohort analysis — giving newsletter operators a data-driven foundation for growth decisions.
Ownership and Data Portability
All three platforms allow you to export your subscriber list — this is non-negotiable when evaluating any publishing platform. However, there are important nuances. Substack's free subscribers are fully portable (export email addresses). Paid subscribers are portable in theory but migrating payment relationships requires active subscriber action (re-subscribing on the new platform), which typically results in 30-50% churn during migrations.
Beehiiv's data portability is the strongest of the three: full export of subscribers, engagement data, and revenue analytics in standard CSV formats. Medium's approach is the weakest for ownership — your readers are Medium's readers, not yours. Medium doesn't provide email addresses for non-Substack-integrated follows, and your content is algorithmically distributed on Medium's terms. Writers serious about building an owned audience should treat Medium as a distribution channel rather than a primary home.
Which Platform Should You Choose?
Choose Substack if: You want to launch a paid newsletter quickly, you already have a social media audience or following on another platform that you can direct to Substack, and you are comfortable with the 10% fee in exchange for Substack's brand recognition and built-in recommendation network. Substack is the fastest path from idea to first paying subscriber for writers who already have an audience to bring to the platform.
Choose Medium if: You are a new writer with no existing audience, you want algorithmic discovery without building your own distribution, and you prefer the ad-supported model (earning from reading time) over the subscription model (managing recurring billing). Medium is the best platform for writers who want to focus purely on writing without managing audience growth, subscription pricing, or marketing.
Choose Beehiiv if: You are serious about building a newsletter as a business — not just a passion project. Beehiiv's advanced analytics, multiple monetization streams (subscriptions + ads + boosts), 0% revenue cut, and sophisticated growth tools make it the highest-ceiling platform for newsletter operators who want to build a multi-thousand-subscriber, multi-revenue-stream operation. The $39/month cost is justified once your newsletter generates $500+/month.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use both Substack and Medium simultaneously?
Yes — many writers publish on both platforms simultaneously. The most common approach is: publish original, full-length content on Substack (for paid subscribers) and republish abbreviated or older pieces on Medium (for organic discovery). This uses Medium as an acquisition channel that drives new readers to discover your Substack newsletter. Set a 7-30 day exclusivity window before republishing on Medium to protect the value of your paid Substack tier.
Does Substack have a free tier?
Yes — Substack is free to use. Writers can publish free newsletters indefinitely with no platform cost. Substack only takes its 10% cut when you activate paid subscriptions and readers actually pay. This makes it genuinely risk-free to start: launch a free newsletter, grow your audience, and only activate paid subscriptions when you have enough engaged readers to convert. There are no monthly fees, setup costs, or minimum revenue requirements.
Is Beehiiv worth the monthly fee?
Beehiiv's paid plans ($39/month for Scale, $99/month for Max) are worth it once your newsletter generates more than $300-500/month in revenue. At that point, the 0% transaction fee versus Substack's 10% cut saves enough money to justify the monthly subscription. Additionally, Beehiiv's ad network can generate supplemental income that offsets the platform cost — a newsletter with 5,000 subscribers earning $2-3 per 1,000 from ads earns $10-15 per send, or $80-120/month from ads alone on a weekly send cadence.
Which platform pays writers the most?
Beehiiv has the highest ceiling for experienced newsletter operators because of its 0% revenue cut on subscriptions plus the additional ad network and boost income. Substack has the highest ceiling for subscription-first writers because of its recommendation algorithm and established paid reader base. Medium has the lowest ceiling but the lowest barrier to entry — it's best for building an initial writing portfolio and discovering which topics resonate before committing to a subscription model on Substack or Beehiiv.
Comments